Saturday 6 February 2010

Facebook = Haram?!!

Imagine swimming and swimming lap after another, searching for a piece of land to rest on, food, water, or anything that could help remind you what it felt like to be human. The swimming tires you, exhausts you, and slowly you begin hallucinating. You see a far away island, one that requires only a few more minutes of moving your restless and weak arms and legs to its direction. You keep moving, and swim even faster to arrive quicker. And it suddenly hits you. Your eyes have betrayed you, and your brain was just teasing. There’s no island. There’s no ending. It’s either the swimming continues with a numb soul, or you give up and let the savage waves take control.

And that’s how I feel every now and then. I love Islam. I feel it’s a beautiful pure religion which always, always, makes sense. It covers everything, and if conducted properly it would make us the happiest people ever. However, (and a big “HOWEVER” this is), Muslims go on and on making their own explanations, creating their own rules, and enforcing their own limited point of views upon it. They either make it ridiculously difficult, because for one reason or another they personally cannot do something allowed in Islam and so they want everyone else to stop doing it. Or, they take it easy – too easy – and try to explain why they personally believe something should be allowed while it clearly isn’t.

And here is where I fit in. I don’t claim to understand every part of this great religion, but I can say that I know the basics. I know how I’m supposed to live, to think, to feel and to “deal” with people/issues according to Islamic teachings. But lately, I feel all I do is defend Islam. Explain why some people did something wrong, and how they linked it to Islam, but it really isn’t Islam – they just misunderstood it. I just wish I could one day stop defending. Stop explaining. I wish Muslims would act as Muslims, rather than act upon their personal beliefs and say those are Islam’s beliefs. I wish there’s an ending to this tiresome battle with the savage waves.

The latest Fatwa is a typical example. According to yesterday’s Muscat Daily, a top Egyptian cleric from Al-Azhar issued a “fatwa forbidding the use of popular social networking site Facebook” !!!!! And why is it forbidden? Because it “encourages spouses to have relations with other people”. Well I guess I’m going to hell then, since I’m very into Facebook and I check it every day!

Aaaarrrggghhhh!!!! Nothing about the Fatwa makes sense! It just makes Muslims look ridiculous. As if all we think of is having relationships with other people. As if we never knew how to do it before until Facebook, hurray, came to existence. As if we are so weak, so stupid, and so naïve, that we would easily fall for any friend request and the next day betray our spouses because our new “friend’s” profile picture was so gorgeous we couldn’t resist it. How sad.

It’s even Haram in Islam to say something is Haram while it isn’t. Any Fatwa has to have some concrete basis. I don’t see any basis, let alone solid basis, for this Fatwa.

But I suppose I cannot lose hope. Hope for change, and hope for a world where both Muslims and non-Muslims understand Islam better. But I need help in this – and dearest readers do help me out. Let’s erase these misunderstandings, let’s think and analyze and understand better, let’s use common sense rather than traditional viewpoints and ancestors’ beliefs. As Lin Yutang says it:

“Hope is like a road in the country; there was never a road, but when many people walk on it, the road comes into existence.”

12 comments:

  1. -I'm afraid I am among those people who make things too complicated for lack of understanding or willingness to submit-something I AM working on :) This was very interesting.

    As for facebook? Hmm...I cringe at the thought. Being a recovering myspace addict myself, I won't knock facebook and say it's outright haram. I do believe that it can be used in a fun, halal manner...BUT..FOR ME PERSONALLY...FB is one of many things wrong with my marriage. My husband feels it's perfectly find to have a fb page, HIDDEN-so hidden I cannot find him if I wanted too-with friends of both sexes from now and the past-girls and guys-and this is where I do believe the haram part comes in FOR ME at least and I THINK Islamically. 1. the secret of hiding it 2. the having non mahrems on his friends list that he writes or responds too 3. being able to look at the photos of those non mahrems-vice versa and a few others but you get my point.
    I don't find it fitting for me as a Muslim woman to carry on with a man that I am not related to in public, private, online what have you...it's just not right. It's not Islamic. And I expect that from my husband-who seems to think there is nothing wrong with it. He is not cheating, so in his mind, he is doing nothing wrong. But my question is...if it were this simple, then why are Muslims forbidden from having casual contact for no good reason with non mahrems? And wouldn't this be what MOST people do on fb without thinking it's wrong-but not acknowledging that IT CAN(CAN=key word)lead to fantasy, flirting, flings...etc etc etc..??!

    Just my two cents lol..but I don't think Muslims needed a fatwa to know the difference between right and wrong. If we'd just adhere to the PROPER Islamic ways, then I doubt we'd need half of these dumb fatwas. and pretty sure FB wouldn't be such a hit with Muslims either

    I like you blog :D

    ReplyDelete
  2. okay...so next time I will proof read and try to catch the spelling mistakes lol

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nobody,

    (I feel weird calling you that, but lol I guess I have to!)

    I love how you considered your personal circumstances and highlighted them instead of generalizing your opinion. It shows that you, unlike that Shaikh, have an open mind - and even if it could apply to you differently (i.e. FB could be wrong for you) you still wouldn't say it's haram, full stop.

    And that's exactly my point. Everything in this world could be used in a right or wrong way. Even marriage, something very encouraged in Islam, could be done for extremely wrong reasons and be deemed a definite HARAM. But it's wrong to say something is Haram because "it could lead to Haram things". Everything could lead to Haram things.

    I understand how frustrating it would feel if my husband chats with numerous FB female friends. But that's not because of FB. That's a mixture of my husband's behaviour/attitude/principles, my own attitude/principles, AND me and my husband's relationship. Instead of forbidding it, the Shaikh could've highlighted any commmon wrong actions that could be done using FB, or emphasized on "good Muslim values" instead.

    But thanks for sharing, keep commenting :)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Bubu,

    Thanks! I appreciate your comment, and do visit/comment more often!

    Will definitely visit your blog as soon as time allows me to :)

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think all religions are misinterpreted by a minority and this is very frustrating. Living in this amazing part of the world it never ceases to amaze me about how Muslims are viewed by some idiots in the West... but then we all have to do our own little bit to rid misconceptions. Great post :)

    ReplyDelete
  6. That's true ED, thanks and keep visiting :)

    ReplyDelete
  7. You're right! It's not fb and I think I could have worded it better or thought that through a little more before commenting :)
    I say its one of many problems but in reality-it's one of many problems between he and I that just so happen to have something to do with the site BUT NOT the site itself.

    It is all what you do and how you do it... Like you said. I think we need to use our God given sense of right and wrong a little more often in a lot of situations

    I dont think we need someone else to tell us what is forbidden and not when Allah clearly tells us already. Maybe a reminder of our actions that can be attributed somehow to certain things-as you put it-but I wouldn't go further than that.

    ~Shelly :)

    ReplyDelete
  8. So true, thanks Shelly :)

    And Princess.. Well Arabs do misuse many things, but I wouldn't say everything ;) Welcome to the blog!

    ReplyDelete
  9. My mind out loud.

    When I first heard of the fatwa, I was shocked. Shocked because I use FB and have not seen how can it lead to making relationships, etc. Then realized the fact that I only accept 'my real life' friends.

    Which made me think on a wider range. People misuse things. Internet, in general, have both the positive and negative sides and that mainly depends on the person him/her self. Whether to make the most of it, or simply ruin their own lives, and sin in the same process.

    Interesting blog. Keep writing, and I shall keep following.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Kitten,

    Firstly, welcome to the blog! I'm glad you like it :)

    I agree. If misused, FB could be a means to numerous sins. But my point again is, it's not FB that should be forbidden. It's the end goal that could be Haram, e.g. sex with a stranger, showing off body parts, whatever! And this end goal should be emphasized, warned, and explained, rather than forbidding a website outright.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Very well written post, Stimulus.

    The first thought that came to my mind when I read the fatwa was this: How Pathetic! The problem is certainly not with social online networks, but with people who don't know how to control their misguided emotions.

    What frustrates me the most about it, is that this fatwa according to the Azhar, is the outcome of heavy, ongoing research into why divorce rate has been increasing in Egypt, and they concluded that facebook is the 'devil' behind it. Do they not see that those people will still find alternative ways to fulfil their emotional needs, and that banning facebook will not magically turn them into saints? If a person cheats through facebook, he/she can cheat through other means too.

    I cannot agree with you more that the 'end goal' should be targetted, and not the means, because any medium can be misused if intentions are corrupt.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Exactly, Alma, exactly.

    About the divorce rate correlating with FB.. All I can say is, Pfffffffffffffff

    ReplyDelete

Please leave a comment :)